Posted on 2 Comments

Robert Mondavi Private Selection Merlot California 2015 Review

A quick video today of this Robert Mondavi Private Reserve California Merlot 2015 review, plus some quick stories on Robert Mondavi the man, who built the brand before that was a thing.

Video Transcription:

Hi guys. Mark Aselstine with Uncorked Ventures. I’m joined today by a bottle of, I’ll hold this up. This is Robert Mondavi Private Selection Merlot from, well, just pretty generically, California in 2015. A couple of things. First, Mondavi obviously not a fit for our Wine Club program. Obviously, we really too well known when huge, although I don’t think they get enough credit for producing really, really great wine on the higher end, this obviously is not one of those. The private selection label runs between 10 and $15 per bottle, depending on where you live and if it’s Merlot, it’s a little bit cheaper than say, Pinot or whatever.

So a couple things, so first as far as kind of these large national brands where they’re producing a million showcases a year, if you open one of these most of the time you’re going to say, “Hey, that was good.” Not like this was life altering, not that this was memorable, but also not that this was bad or I think I got hosed by opening this. And that’s in large part because they test this stuff. They know exactly the flavor profile that they need to hit, they knew the acidity numbers that people like, they know the tannin numbers that people like, and they will pick grapes the exact point that they need to, to get to this point during every vintage and if they can’t, then they’re happy to do a little bit of additives and stuff to get it there.

So we’ve done a number of private tastings with people over the years and we’ll bring in a really expensive bottle, we’ll bring in kind of something like this, and then we’ll bring in a couple of other stuff that we know is a little further out there palate-wise, and almost exclusively the really expensive bottle does win most of the time. But then the most generic one almost always finishes second, and that’s just because it is so [inaudible 01:34].

So Mondavi now, these days, most people are aware the winery’s public traded, it is kind of what it is. It was kind of the first Napa Valley winery to get that kind of level of both fame and kind of outside investment, I guess. Mondavi himself, Robert, it’s an interesting story. I won’t go into the sordid family details, suffice to say, I’ve had conversation with a number of the old heads, as you might call them, in Napa and they will refer to Robert as Bob. You hear stories like, “We were farming it ourselves, my son and I, we had these pests in the vineyard and we couldn’t figure out what was going. So I called Bob or I happened to see him at lunch and I told him what was going on, and then like two hours later the entire Mondavi crew, fully time vineyard crew, would show up and take care of whatever it was.”

I’ve heard that from multiple people over the years. And I think it’s one of those things where we don’t think about Mondavi in that way, as far as being started by a person and a family, but Robert Mondavi really was a family business for quite a long time. And I see that from people that I deal with that worked there when he was in charge still. And I see that from family members that have moved on to other aspects of the wine industry.

So I don’t think Robert Mondavi gets nearly the credit, both as the person nor as the winery, and the breeding ground it was for professional wine sales people that I’ve run into, but also professional wine educators and also people that just treat the industry like a way to cash out.

Once again, Mark Aselstine with Uncorked Ventures.

2 thoughts on “Robert Mondavi Private Selection Merlot California 2015 Review

  1. I am a fan of Mondavi wines. I enjoy many California wines and look for them on menu’s. I recently purchased a bottle of RM Private Selection Merlot 2015 , it was on sale and you can’t go wrong with a Mondavi, right? Wrong. The worst bottle of wine, ever. I poured a glass when I got home and thought it was bitter and acidic. Thought it was me, poured it down the drain. Poured a glass the next day and I have to say it was still horrible. Not turned or gone bad but bitter and acidic. Is this all Private selections?

  2. I enjoyed the 2015 regularly for all of last year. Noticed the 2016 was even better!! I plan to stockpile a dozen bottles towards the end of the year. The 2015 was corked w plastic plugs. The 2016 have cork…with the distinctive stain on the end. Could that make a difference???

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.